Mexican Hypocrisy on Illegal Immigration

Unbelievable:

A Mexican Senate committee passed a measure Wednesday urging President Felipe Calderon to send a diplomatic note to the United States protesting the deportation of an illegal migrant who took refuge in a Chicago church for a year.

[. . .]

Elvira Arellano, 32, became an activist and a national symbol for illegal immigrant parents by defying her deportation order and speaking out from her sanctuary in the Adalberto United Methodist Church. She announced last week that she was leaving to try to lobby U.S. lawmakers for immigration reform.

[. . .]

“We cannot remain quiet in view of this injustice and must ask for firm action from our authorities,” Mexican Sen. Humberto Zazue said.

[. . .]

“For me it is very important that our government take a strong stand to defend all of us who decide to migrate to another country,” she said. (emphasis added)

Yet Mexican authorities must understand the issue, at least on some level:

…Mexico deports around 200,000 migrants from other Latin American nations annually…

I guess the keyword that is escaping these people is ILLEGAL. One cannot decide to immigrate to another country without that countries permission. Clearly Elvira Arellano did not have that permission, and so was deported. If she wants to come legally, good for her. But she didn’t. Simple.

I wonder if the Mexican Senate could explain why Elvira Arellano should be allowed to break U.S. laws when Mexico routinely deports illegal Central and South American illegals?

5 Responses to “Mexican Hypocrisy on Illegal Immigration ”


  1. 1 Juan Gregs Aug 24th, 2007 at 1:04 pm

    Mexico receives the bulk of their income from remittances from the USA. This is pure profit - and it’s larger than any other Mexican industry. It is Mexico.

    So if anything gets in the way of their cash cow - Mexico cries foul. The Mexican government even funds the Mexican legal defense fund and others (Maldef, LA RAZA, etc) to use our laws to allow Mexicans to stay in the US - after doing so illegally.

    We must stop the flood. Immigration is great. An uncontrolled flood is NOT!!!!

  2. 2 Richardson Aug 24th, 2007 at 7:52 pm

    Hello Juan,
    Very good points, and I’d like to be clear that, like you, it is illegal immigration that concerns me rather than the legal sort;

    http://www.areastudies.org/2007/05/30/off-topic-us-politics/

  3. 3 Dee Aug 25th, 2007 at 11:20 am

    Hi Richardson, Most¨”PRO”s do not support Arellano although we do support Comprehensive Immigration Reform. I´ve posted the PRO view on my blog: http://immigrationmexicanamerican.blogspot.com/
    (please visit and comment)

    Additionally, remittances to MX are down, that may be why the MX politicians are up in arms.
    “Investors Business Daily is reporting Illegal Immigration is Down and Mexican Jobs Up. They are also saying the Border Patrol is reporting Illegal immigration apprehensions are down 38% from October ‘06 through June ‘07 because the rate of those coming over the border is down and so many illegal immigrants are leaving. Additionally, remittances are down to only.6% for the first half of 2007 (vs 23% the first half of 2006).”

  4. 4 jennifergribble Sep 24th, 2007 at 10:16 am

    I live in a small town rt 95 runs straight through it.I want to help some way because the population here,is mixed but I need help.It seems to me that the local police cant do anything about the Mexicans without papers even if they drive drunk without a drivers liscence,insurance or plates.This is absoultly not correct some how!State nor local law enforcement here just pick them up take them to jail then let them go in the morning!I have said company names that hire illegle imangrants because its cheap labor.NO ONE CARES!!!If a person without papers just so happens to get arrested by immagration they let them go too!!If someone picks them up and takes them out of a van.One named Miguel Catillo-vigalomez and Ricardo Morales-Meza they live on Moral street right across from the police station.My name is Jennifer and I am an AMERICAN!!!girl

  5. 5 Opus Vax Oct 18th, 2007 at 4:21 pm

    If we would recognize that Illegal Immigrants are being used “Economic SLAVES” (ie substandard pay and living conditions) then we could deport them for humanitarian reasons.



Recent Comments

  • Paleo guy: I lived in Colorado and the seashells are not from when the ice...
  • Javar: So much of this mess going i just found http://www.clintonlies.info Jav
  • Personal: lol. That’s simply amazing. Rather than allow their children...
  • Richard Payne: Col. Daughtry is my great uncle. He did take time to share...
  • Janus: I want one.
  • John Morris: Interesting find. Bill Clinton certainly has his way of using...
  • Richardson: Yes, it is! What are they afraid of?
  • usinkorea: That’s delicious in so many ways…

Recent Posts


Reassessing Rich and Poor
Seven Years
Saddam Bluffed, Didn't Have But Wanted WMD
Powerful Rail Gun Delivered to U.S. Navy
Where France is Right - Nuclear Power
Gmail vs. Yahoo Mail
Surprise! (not really) Guns Don't Equal Crime
The NYT Still Doesn't Get It





    Security, Politics, Etc.


    Best of the Web
    Black Five
    Counterterrorism Blog
    DPRK Studies
    Forward Deployed
    Gypsy Scholar
    MilBlogs
    Peaktalk
    Proliferation Press
    Real Clear Politics Blog
    The Long War Journal
    USinKorea's Journal

    Survival


    How To Be a Survivor
    Nuclear Survival by State
    Pragmatic Survivalist
    Survival Blog
    Survivalism

    Technology


    Engadget
    Gizmodo
    Lifehacker

    Think Tanks, Etc.


    American Enterprise Institute
    Brookings Institution
    CATO Institute
    Center for Defense Information
    Center for Strategic and Intl Studies
    Council on Foreign Relations
    Federation of American Scientists
    Global Security
    Heritage Foundation
    Middle East Media Research Institute
    RAND Corporation



    All Rights Reserved. © 2000-2007 DPRK Studies (dprkstudies.org).

    Bad Behavior has blocked 227 access attempts in the last 7 days.